
Who Taught Teachers to Intervene?
Who Taught Teachers to Intervene?
By Quanita Joseph, Founder & Structured Literacy Educator
This past July, I presented "The System That Scaled: Redefining Literacy Across 42 States" at the Houston Area Alliance of Black School Educators (HAABSE) conference, sharing how we built a literacy intervention model that serves students across the country.
While I was there, I asked a room full of experienced educators one question.
"How many of you have been trained to analyze your own student data and use it to make intervention decisions?"
Not a single hand went up.
I wondered if I had worded the question poorly, so I flipped it.
"How many of you have never been trained to do this?"
Every hand went up.
I was floored. These were not new teachers. Most were veterans with advanced degrees and a track record of getting results with students.
When I asked how they learned to interpret assessment data, identify specific learning gaps, and choose interventions, their answers were remarkably similar.
They figured it out themselves. They learned through years of classroom experience and trial and error.
I admire their commitment to their craft, but it left me asking: Why are we leaving something this important for teachers to figure out on their own?
The problem with figuring it out over time
According to a 2025 report from the Center for American Progress, approximately 44% of new teachers leave the profession within their first five years.
Consider what that means. The educators in that room spent a decade or more developing their ability to analyze data and make intervention decisions. Yet a substantial share of new teachers leave before they ever reach that point.
Even for the teachers who stay, how many students pass through their classrooms while they are still figuring out how to intervene effectively? Those are years of instruction that students do not get back.
We cannot afford to make experience the primary training model for something this important.
We train teachers to teach. Do we train them to intervene?
We expect classroom teachers to differentiate instruction, analyze student performance, run small-group interventions, and close learning gaps. How much preparation do they actually receive to do those things?
According to the National Center for Education Statistics, 77.2% of public school teachers surveyed in 2020–21 reported completing coursework in learning assessment before their first year of teaching. However, nearly 40% had not completed coursework on how to use student performance data to inform instruction before their first year of teaching.
A 2026 report from the National Center for Learning Disabilities and WestEd, based on a national educator survey, found that only 43% of general educators reported being comfortable selecting academic interventions to address students' skill gaps.
Fewer than half of general educators felt comfortable with one of the most important decisions in intervention. Most surprisingly, veteran teachers reported comparable rates of discomfort as novice teachers. This negates the common belief that years in the classroom automatically builds confidence in making intervention decisions.
Identifying the problem is not the same as knowing how to fix it
Schools have invested heavily in collecting student data. We have universal screeners, diagnostic assessments, benchmark assessments, progress monitoring tools, and data meetings. In 2023–24, the National Center for Education Statistics reported that 88% of public schools used diagnostic assessment data to identify individual students' academic needs.
But what happens after a student is identified?
For classroom teachers, intervention often happens through small-group instruction, an approach research supports when it is targeted to students' instructional needs. But effective small groups do not happen just because students are pulled together. Teachers must know how to analyze assessment data, identify specific skill gaps, group students by those needs, select evidence-based resources, and monitor whether students are making progress.
We have become very good at identifying students who need help, and we have not prepared teachers to provide it.
Have we shifted intervention expertise to instructional coaches?
I have noticed another pattern in schools. Rather than developing teachers' ability to analyze data and make intervention decisions, we sometimes shift much of that responsibility to instructional coaches and intervention specialists.
The coach analyzes the assessment data, identifies the instructional gaps, forms the student groups, and recommends next steps. The classroom teacher receives the plan.
There is nothing wrong with specialists supporting those decisions. That is part of what makes coaching valuable. But we need to ask whether that support is building teachers' expertise or simply completing the work for them.
If the coach is always the one analyzing the data and deciding what happens next, when does the teacher learn to make those decisions independently? And what happens when that coach leaves?
The goal should be to build that expertise throughout the entire building.
What needs to change?
A 2022 meta-analysis of 33 studies on data literacy training for K–12 teachers found that collaborative training formats produced stronger effects. That is a useful guide for how we build this skill.
Teacher preparation and professional development should include explicit training in analyzing student data, identifying the underlying learning difficulty, selecting evidence-based interventions, and evaluating whether those interventions are working.
Instructional coaches should model that process and gradually hand responsibility over to teachers.
Data meetings should help teachers build their instructional reasoning, not simply hand them reports and new group assignments.
New teachers should receive this support from day one, rather than spending years trying to figure it out.
These skills can be developed on purpose. The question is whether we are making their development a priority.
We have spent years building systems to identify students who need intervention. It is time to put the same effort into training the teachers responsible for providing it.
So I will leave school leaders with the question I have not stopped thinking about since that conference.
Who taught your teachers to intervene?
Sources
Center for American Progress. (2025). How to Increase the Retention of Early Career Teachers.
National Center for Education Statistics. (2020–21). National Teacher and Principal Survey: Teacher Education and Preparation.
National Center for Learning Disabilities & WestEd. (2026). The State of Learning Disabilities: Strengthening Educator Confidence to Support Every Learner.
National Center for Education Statistics. (2024). School Pulse Panel: About a Third of Public School Students Ended the 2023–24 School Year Behind Grade Level.
Filderman, M. J., Toste, J. R., Didion, L., & Peng, P. (2022). Data Literacy Training for K–12 Teachers: A Meta-Analysis of the Effects on Teacher Outcomes. Remedial and Special Education, 43(5), 328–343.